Pine Needle Mulch Vs Hardwood Mulch

Offers a better weed barrier and it s easier to pull weeds for mulch.

Pine needle mulch vs hardwood mulch.

Pros for pine straw. To provide you with a better understanding of the two here is a close look at the different factors and the way the two are similar or different. Some people prefer the aesthetic look of pine straw over mulch especially in areas with dense pine tree cover. It has to be refreshed more often than mulch.

Pine needles aka pine straw hardwood mulch is alkaline. Pine straw mulch comes from pine tree needles which are raked and baled for use as mulch so the product is renewable and is naturally sourced. The material a homeowner chooses to use as the base of the beds differ in the areas of application cost maintenance longevity safety and interaction with the plants. Cons for pine straw.

Benefits of using mulch. Colored wood mulch is often made from recycled wood that can contain objectionable additives including arsenic from pressure treated wood and is not always 100 hardwood pressure treated wood containing arsenic was phased out a decade ago by the epa but old crates and pallets may still be entering the recycling stream. Pine needles are acidic. It s cheaper easier to handle and transport.

It s easy to rearrange. Here is a example of the finished look of mulch. Mulch performs a key role in an attractive healthy garden or landscape but the array of choices can prove daunting. Pros for pine straw.

It can add too much acid to your soil. Mulch vs pine straw. They will hold where most mulches will slide or float during rain storms. It s less expensive than mulch at least in the short run.

If budget is an important consideration then pine straw is a great choice. The most popular materials for filling beds include wood chips mulch and pine straw. You may need to amend soil to counteract this if your plants have a strong preference. Pine bark and hardwood mulches make up just two.

Nonetheless this price benefit is noticeable only in the short term. It s easy to spread. Hardwood mulch is heavier so it s not as easy to move but it s usually a little better for the soil as it decomposes. However they do biodegrade more quickly and therefore need to be replenished more frequently which offsets.

Pine needles are easier to place in the beds and also cost about as much as mulch. Before we move to mulch let s look at the cons. Pine needles are less expensive and go further.